Surrendering Isn't Giving Up: Finding Safety, Agency, and Hope in the Midst of Betrayal and Addiction

---

One of the most common experiences for both men struggling with sex addiction and women who have been betrayed is a deep sense of unsafety. It shows up in different ways—panic, anxiety, hypervigilance, control, despair—but underneath it all is the same question: Am I safe right now?

Anxiety and fear are not character flaws. They are signals. They function like warning lights on the dashboard, alerting us that something inside of us perceives danger. When we feel unsafe, our nervous systems go on high alert, and instinctively we try to do something—anything—to regain a sense of control.

For many men, that attempt at control has historically taken the form of sexual behaviors, secrecy, image management, or minimizing reality. For many women, it shows up as scanning for danger, trying to manage outcomes, or desperately attempting to make sense of a reality that no longer feels stable.

And yet, one of the great paradoxes of healing is this: the more unsafe we feel, the more we try to control—and the more we try to control what we cannot control, the more unsafe we become.

This is where the concept of surrender enters the conversation—and why it is often misunderstood.

Surrender vs. Giving Up vs. Acquiescing

When people hear the word surrender, many immediately think it means giving up. For betrayed partners, surrender can feel like accepting injustice or staying in harm’s way. For men in addiction, it can sound like admitting defeat or weakness.

But surrender is not giving up—and it is not passively acquiescing either.

There is a crucial distinction:

• Acquiescing is passive. It is being overwhelmed by circumstances and letting them define you.

• Giving up is resignation—losing hope and agency.

• Surrender, by contrast, is an active, courageous choice to face reality truthfully and respond wisely.

Wise people surrender. Survivors acquiesce.

Surrender begins when we name what is true, even when the truth is painful, disappointing, or terrifying. It means acknowledging reality instead of resisting it, minimizing it, or trying to wish it away. While surrender involves letting go, it also paradoxically restores agency and power

The Cost of Resisting Reality

Both men and women often resist reality for understandable reasons.

• Men may minimize the impact of their behavior to protect their image or avoid shame.

• Women may resist reality because the truth threatens their sense of safety, attachment, and future.

But resisting reality comes at a cost.

When we refuse to engage what is true, we often turn to wishful thinking, fantasy, or false hope—hoping things will improve without evidence that change is actually happening. This kind of resistance may temporarily numb pain, but it ultimately keeps people stuck.

Truth sets us free—but not all truth feels freeing at first.

Some truth hurts. Some truth has consequences. And yet, even painful truth creates more freedom than living inside denial, distortion, or false narratives. When we resist truth, we step into a different kind of bondage—one that quietly drains hope and agency.

When Reality Hits Too Fast

For many betrayed partners, discovering trauma creates a new reality almost overnight. What they thought they knew collides with information they never wanted to learn. The nervous system struggles to keep up.

This is why betrayal often feels surreal.

One moment you’re living in one version of reality, and the next it’s as if someone pushed you out of a plane without warning. At first, there’s no context—just shock, disorientation, and sensory overload. Only later, sometimes weeks or months later, does the reality fully land.

This delay does not mean someone is in denial. It means the human mind and body need time to integrate overwhelming information.

The brain and the central nervous system are incredible, in that they temporarily numb emotions to allow a person to continue functioning without severe pain and immediate emotional overwhelm.

Surrender in these early stages does not mean forcing acceptance. It means gently, compassionately allowing reality to come into focus at a pace the nervous system can tolerate.

The Pendulum: Minimizing vs. Catastrophizing

When facing painful truth, people often swing to one of two extremes:

1.     Minimizing – “It’s not that bad. I should just get over it.”

2.     Catastrophizing – “This will never get better. Everything is ruined.”

Neither extreme reflects truth.

Minimizing denies pain and impact. Catastrophizing strips away hope.

One marker that someone has slipped outside of reality is the absence of hope. Because of who God is, hope always exists—even when circumstances are deeply broken. Living in truth means rightsizing reality: neither minimizing nor exaggerating it, but staying grounded in what is actually happening right now.

Powerlessness and Agency: Both Matter

A foundational aspect of surrender is learning to differentiate between:

• What I am powerless over

• Where I still have agency

This distinction is essential for both men and women.

You are powerless over:

• Another person’s choices

• Another person’s recovery

• Past events you did not choose

You have agency over:

• How you respond

• How you care for yourself

• The boundaries you set

• The support you seek

• The next right step you take

Naming powerlessness can feel terrifying. It often triggers grief, anger, and fear. But clarity about powerlessness is what makes wise surrender possible. Without it, people either attempt to control what they cannot—or collapse into helplessness.

Surrender Is Counterintuitive—and That’s the Point

When we feel unsafe, our instinct is to tighten our grip.

But surrender asks us to do something profoundly counterintuitive: instead of trying to control what is out of control, we surrender to our out-of-control-ness.

Think of:

• A car skidding on ice

• Being caught in a riptide

• Whitewater rafting through rapids

In each case, fighting the current increases danger. Survival comes not from domination, but from alignment—learning how to move with reality rather than against it.

Life after betrayal or in early recovery often feels like being carried downstream. You may not get to choose the river—but you still get to choose how you navigate the rapids.

Why Community Matters So Much

No one is meant to surrender alone.

In whitewater rafting, safety comes from:

• A life vest

• A guide who knows the river

• Others in the boat

Recovery works the same way.

Community provides:

• Perspective when yours is blurred

• Hope when you cannot access it

• Wisdom about options you cannot yet see

Especially in early stages, borrowed hope is often necessary. Wise guides help people discern choices, boundaries, and next steps when everything feels overwhelming.

A Real Example: When a Partner Stops Recovery

Consider a common scenario: a wife discovers that her husband has decided he’s “done enough” recovery. He stops therapy, group, or accountability. She feels anxious, powerless, and afraid.

Surrender here does not mean approval.It means facing the truth:

• I cannot make him choose recovery.

• I am powerless over his decisions.

From there, agency re-emerges:

• What boundaries do I need for safety?

• How do I care for my own trauma?

• What support do I need right now?

This is not punishment. It is stewardship of self. Surrender shifts the focus from controlling another person to responsibly caring for one’s own healing and stability.

Surrendering Today—not the Whole Future

One of the ways anxiety tries to regain control is by future-tripping—mentally living months or years ahead and making decisions without sufficient information.

Surrender often means narrowing the focus:

• What is true today?

• What do I need to surrender today?

• What is my next right step?

Living fully in an imagined future can become another form of control. Wise surrender stays anchored in the present, while remaining open to change over time.

For Men: Powerless in Addiction, Powerful in Recovery

For men struggling with sex addiction, surrender is central—not optional.

The first step of recovery is admitting powerlessness over addictive behavior. This does not mean helplessness. It means acknowledging that willpower alone has failed.

Here is the paradox:

• I am powerless in my addiction.

• I am powerful in my recovery.

Agency returns through honesty, community, structure, accountability, and humility. Surrendering image, reputation, and control opens the door to the freedom many men have been chasing for years.

Letting Go: The Vine You’re Clinging To

A powerful image of surrender is found in old Tarzan movies. To grab the next vine, Tarzan must let go of the one he’s holding. Hanging on too long means falling.

Surrender invites a hard question:What am I gripping that I’m afraid to release?

For some, it’s control.For others, it’s image.For others still, it’s an old story, identity, or coping strategy.

As one saying goes: either let go—or be dragged.

Letting go does not guarantee comfort, but it often opens the door to a life you did not know was possible.

Surrender Is Not Weakness

Surrender takes courage.It takes honesty.It takes trust.

It is not passive resignation—it is active alignment with truth. And for both men and women on this journey, surrender is often the doorway into real safety, authentic power, and lasting hope.

Not because circumstances magically change—but because you do.

To view the podcast on this topic, please visit https://youtu.be/XPxu_igoTNc

---